Skip to main content

Site Navigation

Your Account

Choose Language

Help

Current version by: jayeff ,

Text:

Hi @kristen @danj
 
Can a Mac expert please look at this guide[https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Pro+13-Inch+Function+Keys+2017+Won%E2%80%99t+Turn+On+Repair/133534?permalink=1#comment-665196|guide] and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?
Can a Mac expert please look at this guide[https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Pro+13-Inch+Function+Keys+2017+Won%E2%80%99t+Turn+On+Repair/133534?permalink=1#comment-665196|guide] and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?
 
There seems to be an ongoing problem between the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful. The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.
 
The author of the guide keeps on voting on the Answers Moderation page that the comments be deleted as spam/offensive, which has just happened yesterday, when the moderation received enough votes but then they have been reposted again by the commentator not long afterwards, although the new comments are slightly different in what they state this time.
 
It’s a shame that I cannot link the comment that has already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in it as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig it out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 7/21/20 @  04:19:34 AM
 
Cheers.

Status:

open

Edit by: jayeff ,

Text:

Hi @kristen @danj
 
Can a Mac expert please look at this guide and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?
 
There seems to be an ongoing stoushproblem between the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful. The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.
There seems to be an ongoing stoushproblem between the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful. The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.
 
The author of the guide keeps on voting on the Answers Moderation page that the comments be deleted as spam/offensive, which has just happened yesterday, when the moderation received enough votes but then they have been reposted again by the commentator not long afterwards, although the new comments are slightly different in what they state this time.
 
It’s a shame that I cannot link the comment that has already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in it as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig it out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 7/21/20 @  04:19:34 AM
 
Cheers.

Status:

open

Edit by: jayeff ,

Text:

Hi @kristen @danj
 
Can a Mac expert please look at this guide and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?
 
There seems to be an ongoing stoush between the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful. The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.
 
The author of the guide keeps on voting on the Answers Moderation page that the comments be deleted as spam/offensive, which has just happened yesterday, when the moderation received enough votes but then they have been reposted again by the commentator not long afterwards, although the new comments are slightly different in what they state this time.
 
It’s a shame that I cannot link the comment that has already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in it as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig it out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 21/7/207/21/20 @  04:19:34 AM
It’s a shame that I cannot link the comment that has already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in it as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig it out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 21/7/207/21/20 @  04:19:34 AM
 
Cheers.

Status:

open

Edit by: jayeff ,

Text:

Hi @kristen @danj
 
Can a Mac expert please look at this guide and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?
 
There seems to be an ongoing stoush between the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful. The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.
 
The author of the guide keeps on voting on the Answers Moderation page that the comments be deleted as spam/offensive, which has just happened yesterday, when the moderation received enough votes but then they have been reposted again by the commentator not long afterwards, although the new comments are slightly different in what they state this time.
 
It’s a shame that I cannot link the commentscomment that havehas already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in themit as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig themit out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 21/7/20 @  04:19:34 AM
It’s a shame that I cannot link the commentscomment that havehas already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in themit as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig themit out to get a better picture. The original comment (now deleted) was posted by the commentator on 21/7/20 @  04:19:34 AM
 
Cheers.

Status:

open

Original post by: jayeff ,

Text:

Hi @kristen  @danj

Can a Mac expert please look at this guide and also check the “comments” attached at the bottom of the guide please, to either substantiate the claim made in the comments or refute them and then inform both parties, as to what is correct?

There seems to be an ongoing stoush between  the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/3274962/Phryne|author of the guide] and the [https://www.ifixit.com/User/1885249/Seff+Ka|user making the comments] about whether the guide is OK or harmful.  The author hasn’t actually taken the commentator to task about the claims, with any follow up comments of their own in the guide as yet though.

The author of the guide keeps on voting on the Answers Moderation page that the comments be deleted as spam/offensive, which has just happened yesterday, when the moderation received enough votes but then they have been reposted again by the commentator not long afterwards, although the new comments are slightly different in what they state this time.

It’s a shame that I cannot link the comments that have already been deleted by popular vote in the Answers Moderation page as there was more information in them as to what the commentator thinks is wrong with the guide, but perhaps the admin can still dig them out to get a better picture.

Cheers.

Status:

open