I think this is a really great conversation to have and I commend you, @eke0909, for writing about it here. Meta is the perfect place to look at this process. I brought this to the Community Team this morning and we chatted about a few angles.
First, and foremost, we totally understand (and share with you all) that when people vote without (seemingly) paying attention, it's really annoying and disruptive to our system that you all work so hard at to uphold.
The second thing we talked about with it, is that maybe these users don't really understand our moderation system or how to evaluate the items in the queue. Seems like a great learning opportunity! Along this line of thought: what does everyone think about tagging those users here (in a new Meta post) to ask their reasoning? I typically err on the side of everyone means to do their best and we should reach out to help.
I think a post containing the following could be helpful (but I'm 100% open to suggestions!):
* a @tag to grab the users attention
* a link to the post in question
* your thoughts behind why their decision was incorrect
* a request for why they chose what they did
* an open invitation to discuss the post
* (if they're new, thank them for contributing to our community =])
