Skip to main content
/

Site Navigation

Your Account

Choose Language

Archived guides are confusing

I was taking a look at this guide, and it has an Archived Guide flag:

This guide is retained solely for historical purposes. Use the updated version of the guide to perform your repair.

However, there's no indication that there is an updated guide of any sort. I'm guessing this means someone decided this device is gone and the guide will never be updated, but that's not at all what the text says, so I'm really just guessing.

Answer this question I have this problem too

Is this a good question?

Score 1
1 Comment

That's a good point, maybe @brittany can look into what's actually going on here.

by

Add a comment

1 Answer

Most Helpful Answer

It may have been archived because we have other, better guides for similar fans. But those guides' procedures are somewhat different, and they are written for specific models rather than for a generic floor fan. In short, I agree that it's pretty confusing!

These days whenever I archive a guide, I include a link in the introduction directing readers to the guide I think they should use instead (here is one example). It's especially important to do this now that the new guide view hides the "Archived" flag from view, because otherwise readers are apt to start the guide without realizing there's a better alternative.

Incidentally, we've used the "Archived" flag somewhat inconsistently in the past. It was sometimes used to mean, "This guide isn't at all up to scratch, and you shouldn't use it—but we don't want to delete this person's work, so we're just going to sweep it to the bottom of the device page where you'll probably never notice it." Eventually we all agreed that was bad policy, and we stopped doing it and clarified the flag's description. But, there are probably still a few guides in the mix that were flagged incorrectly back in the day and need to be fixed.

In this case there's no perfect solution, but I think it may be best to just un-archive the guide.

Was this answer helpful?

Score 2

1 Comment:

I've moved to that as well for guides I archive for age or because I replaced them to age concerns, like the LJ 1012 install guide. I replaced this with a HP UPD guide so I can reliably interchange it as well.

by

Add a comment

Add your answer

James Pearson Hughes will be eternally grateful.