Skip to main content

Site Navigation

Your Account

Choose Language

Discussion Topic

Inconsistent iFixit forum documention pages.

Hi!

When I was about to chime in and answer a recent question here on Meta, I found out that we have multiple documentation/help pages for the same thing, but they contain inconsistent information. These are the two reputation documentation pages:

They list inconsistent reputation scores. Could we update the pages so they align and the information is clearer?

Some examples:

At 20 Reputation:
  • The /Help/Reputation page describes that one can comment, and flag comments.
  • The /Wiki/Reputation page describes that one can:
    • Flag a comment (same).
    • Flag a post (not same, 30 rep according to the /Help/Reputation page)
    • Vote on moderator actions (not same, 100 rep according to the /Help/Reputation page)
Reputation for question edits:
  • The Help/Reputation page describes that one can:
    • Archive a question at 5,000 rep.
    • Delete a question/answer at 20,000.
  • The Wiki/Reputation page describes that one can:
    • Archive/close a question at 5,000 rep (same).
    • Delete a question at 5,000 rep (not same).
Categorization reputation:

According to the /Help/Reputation documentation, one needs 1,000 reputation to edit a Wiki category. However, that wording is a bit unclear, does that mean one can:

  • Edit, approve, and patrol a (re-)categorization at 1,000 reputation?
    • For example, neither I (> 1K rep) nor Sparky (> 1K rep) can approve/patrol categorizations.
  • Make a categorization request?
    • I could categorize my own and other users device pages when I had less than 1K rep. (Reference: I earned 1K rep by the end of February, 2026)

Then the How to Organize Device Categories guide mentions in the Introduction area that "To edit a device or device categories category, you must have >1,000 reputation.", which matches the /Help/Reputation documentation page. However, Step #2 in the guide describes that "An iFixit Admin will have to approve your category suggestion.", which leaves me a bit unsure about what the introduction is meant to indicate.

Conclusion

So, there are multiple documentation pages, that either:

  • Contain unclear wording.
  • Has inconsistent information compared to one another.

Could we update the pages so they align, and make the information clearer?


Thank you for all the hard work that goes into keeping these pages up to date! All of you are so awesome!

Thanks a lot,

Cheers

Reply to discussion Subscribe to discussion

Is this a worthwhile discussion?

Score 2
2 Comments

@meekvixen, Thank you for taking the time to write all of this up, and for being so thorough. It's super helpful!

You're right that the reputation info doesn't line up across the pages right now, and it's something that we are actively working on.

I'm also talking with the rest of the team to see if the device categorization rep threshold is behaving as intended.

Thank you again for reporting this.

I'll follow up as soon as I have an update.

by

@krisrodriguez Thank you so much for handling this :)

by

Add a comment

1 Reply

Most Helpful Answer

Reputation seems to be scored separately on the meta as well, I wonder why that is? I have >1K on the main site but <100 on the meta, which seems strange.

Was this reply helpful?

Score 1

1 Comment:

The two sites are independent construct's.

Think them as identical twins, one is not the other but appear the same!

by

Add a comment

Join the discussion

MeekVixen will be eternally grateful.